Skip to main content

Are your old seeds really just a pack of lies?

Gardening is a game of patience.  You sow your seeds and wait with bated breath until you see the seedlings emerge.  For those of us with a "healthy" stockpile of seeds left over from past seasons, it can be an unwelcome surprise to find that they don't last forever.  The seeds you planted weeks ago have failed to germinate, and now you need a change of plans (or, should I say, plants).  I experienced this firsthand recently, and wanted to share the results of my own experiment.

What is seed germination?

Seed germination is the process by which a plant grows from a seed. It starts when the seed takes up water, which triggers enzymes to break down stored food inside the seed. Once the food is broken down, it provides the energy for the plant embryo to grow roots, a stem, and leaves.

Which seeds are less likely to stay viable after multiple years?

While some seeds can last for decades, others lose viability quickly. The general consensus is that the following types of seeds are unlikely to stay viable after multiple years:

  • Onion and leek
  • Parsley and parsnip
  • Corn, pepper, and eggplant
  • Tomato (can last up to 4 years, but germination rate drops quickly past year 1)

Testing the germination rate of old seeds

How to Guide

To test the germination rate of your seeds, you'll need a few things:

  • Seeds
  • Soft paper product that will hold water, ex: paper towel or coffee filter
  • Water
  • Plastic bag (optional)
  • Permanent marker (optional)

Steps:

  1. Soak the paper towel or coffee filter with water and then squeeze the excess water out, leaving it damp.
  2. Place the old seeds on the damp paper towel or coffee filter, leaving some space between each seed.  I recommend using 10 seeds just to make the percentage calculation easy.  The more seeds you use, the more accurate your result will be.
  3. Fold the paper towel or coffee filter over the seeds so that they are fully covered.
  4. Optional: Put the folded paper towel or coffee filter in the plastic bag and seal it.  If you don't do this, you just need to keep an eye on the paper to ensure that it doesn't dry out.
  5. Optional: Label the bag with the date and the name of the seed.  Alternatively, take a photo of the seeds & seed pack together so the date & info is stored in your phone.
  6. Put the bag in a warm, dark place like a closet or drawer.
  7. Research the "time to germinate" for the specific seed you're testing, and check the seeds after that amount of time to see if they have started to germinate. Some seeds will germinate quickly, while others may take up to 3 weeks.
  8. After another week or so, count the number of seeds that have germinated and divide by the total number of seeds. This will give you the germination rate.
  9. If the germination rate is too low (the threshold is up to you, I would use 50%), it's best to discard the old seeds and purchase new ones.

Real-life Results


Let's say hypothetically that I was recently sold 11 packs of seeds without noticing that the "sow by" dates ranged from December 2014 to December 2017.  Let's use the germination test to see whether any of these are still good.  All of the side-by-side comparison images below were taken 2 weeks apart.

Bean - ?? - Fail 40%

Cabbage - 2016 - Pass 80%

Carrot - 2014 - May need more time

Cantaloupe - 2016 - Fail 0%

Celeriac - 2017 - May need more time

Cucumber - 2015 - Fail 0%

Lettuce - 2015 - Fail 0%

Onion - 2015 - Fail 0%

Onion - 2015 - Fail 0%

Radish - 2015 - Pass 100%

Spinach - 2016 - Fail 10%

Squash - 2016 - Pass 60%

Swiss Chard - 2017 - Pass 50%

Conclusion

If you kept track, only 4 out of the dozen packets of seeds were not total garbage, and the jury's still out on 2 more of them.  Please learn from my mistakes.  In general, it's best to use fresh seeds whenever possible.  If you have a pack of seeds that seems suspiciously (or obviously) old, it's probably not even worth the effort to test them out.  Time lost in the growing season can never be recuperated, so it's a good idea to test the germination rate of any questionable seeds before planting them.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Gardening Guide: Transplanting Seedlings Outdoors 🌱

Photo by Jael Rodriguez on Unsplash Transplanting seedlings from indoor containers to your garden is like graduation day. Your babies are off to make their own way in the world. However, before you take this step, it's important to ensure that the seedlings are properly acclimatized to the outdoor environment. If you need a refresher on hardening off seedlings, check out our Gardening Guide on Hardening Off Seedlings . If you're ready to transplant, read on to discover how to do this in a way that will help your seedlings thrive in their new digs (sorry, plant pun). Step 1: Choose the right time Transplanting seedlings should be done when the weather is suitable. For most crops, the reason you are starting the seedlings indoors in the first place is because you need to wait until the last frost has passed to transplant them outside. However, some more advanced gardeners may choose to start seeds indoors well into the growing season in order to time their transplant with the...

We've moved the blog! ✈

Hey Gardeners! If you're looking for updates on plannt.ca development, general gardening tips, and other fun articles, you can now find us on Medium:  https://plannt.medium.com We will not be posting on this site going forward. Why did we move? Medium is easier to use overall, and has a simpler interface (getting a bit tired of surprise buggy formatting behavior in my Blogger posts!). Medium has a mobile app, which helps a lot for times when I get a sudden idea for a blog post while on the go. Medium offers better exposure opportunities and ways to connect with other writers and publishers. Medium integrates more seamlessly with Twitter. We're able to get the "style" of blog that we're looking for.  We apologize for this blog's appearance 😵 we tried to make the provided templates work, but it's just not happening.  Better subdomain.  Our company name was available as a username- what more could you ask for? We apologize for any inconvenience and, as alwa...

May 2023 Release Notes 🔥 Planning your garden doesn't have to be a drag!

We are thrilled to announce a few of our most notable recent updates to plannt.ca , which includes highly requested features that we're sure our users will love. Rapid Patch Definition We understand that the initial setup of any  garden plan is always a hurdle, especially if you've got a lot of space to work with.  To take the pain out of planning (lnng?), we've added click and drag functionality to Patch Edit Mode to allow you to rapidly define your growing space. This feature is perfect for those who want to be able to quickly experiment with different layouts. Crop Relocation Sticking with the theme of clicking and dragging, we've also added drag-and-drop capability to crops! You can now move a base crop from one patch to another by simply clicking & dragging it over. Whether you're pivoting from your initial plan or simply trying out new ideas, moving crops around in your garden has never been easier! Intuitive Onboarding We're also excited to share that...